Categorized | Balkans

Is the Post-2000 Improvement of Relations Between Serbia and Croatia Irreversible?

An unusual graffito could be seen in central Belgrade after the working visit of Zoran Milanović, the Croatian prime minister, to Serbia on January 16th. It appeared on the wall of University of Belgrade’s Rectorate and said, “Serbs and Croats [are] brothers!” It is arguably the first time since the end of the deadly conflicts in the Western Balkans that such a reconciliatory, though anonymous, public effusion takes place in one of the region’s capitals.

The prime ministerial visit, and the graffito for that matter, was hardly conceivable just a few months ago. Relations between the two neighboring Balkan countries have never been perfect after the conflicts of the 1990’s, but improved notably due to the joint reconciliation efforts of then-Serbian president Boris Tadić and his Croatian counterpart Ivo Josipović. This ‘love affair’ ended with the election of Tomislav Nikolić as president of Serbia last year; his blunt, undiplomatic statements angered both Croatians and Bosnians, while the November ICTY acquittal of two war-time Croatian generals accused of crimes against Serb civilians generated ill-will in Serbia.

Yet a careful look at recent developments indicates that these controversies are properly viewed as temporary drawbacks on a generally consistent path to improved Croatia-Serbia relations.

First, the vehement improvement between ties during the Tadić-Josipović era was in itself extraordinary, and possibly even a bit ahead of its time. Tadić’s Democratic Party (DS) played a crucial role in setting Serbia firmly on the path to democracy, rule of law and European integration – and also, significantly, in opening the country to its neighbors and trying to heal old wounds. Ivo Josipović, for his part, is a center-left, forward-looking politician who established an unprecedented personal friendship with Tadić. So it was only logical that Tadić’s replacement by Nikolić in the late spring of 2012 would cool relations between the two countries, much facilitated by Nikolić’s subsequent media statements.

Second, it was high time the responsibility in bilateral relations shifted to where it belongs – the heads of government, or the executive. Both Serbia and Croatia are parliamentary republics, with strong executive power belonging in the prime minister’s office and the cabinet. Milanovic’s Belgrade visit indicates a shift in bilateral ties to the natural centers of power among each country’s official leadership. This shift has more than institutional implications, too. On a personal level, it will be much easier for Milanović to deal with Dačić than it would be for Josipović to have to handle Nikolić. Nikolić has proved to be a brusque, awkward diplomat who acts and speaks out of personal conviction but is sometimes unaware that tact is more effective in relations among nations. Dačić, on the other hand is the most down-to-earth, efficient and truly working politician in Serbia at the present moment. His controversial past as the speaker for Slobodan Milošević has been overshadowed by his willingness to get the job done, especially as concerns Belgrade’s talks with Pristina, and good neighborly relations in general, vis-à-vis Serbia’s bid to start accession talks with the European Union this year. Unlike the star of the day, Aleksandar Vučić, the deputy prime minister, who has conquered public opinion polls with his massive, and loud, campaign of anti-corruption investigations and arrests, Dačić gives the impression of the reformed pragmatic who quietly moves forward in pursuing Serbia’s most important goals, progress on the EU path and normalization of relations with Kosovo, for that purpose. He may have also a personal ambition – to become the EU’s new favorite in Belgrade and thus remain a relevant political factor in view of the danger posed by Vučić’s growing popularity at home and the uncertain outcome of a possible early parliamentary election which could see Dačić’s Socialists thrown out of the ruling coalition.

Finally, but perhaps most important, the constant, benign impact of the EU’s soft power on both Serbia and Croatia, whoever is in power, will guarantee that bilateral relations will be improving rather than deteriorating. This soft power should not be explicitly understood as face-to-face meetings and direct Commission or MemberState pressure on the leaders of the two countries. The real soft power of the EU lies in the accession perspective, which continues to be a strong magnet and leverage tool all across the Western Balkans, despite the continued crisis in Europe. The Serbian and Croatian foreign ministers have commented that Milanović’s visit was made through the initiative of the two countries rather than at the behest of the EU, and took place early in the timeframe initially envisioned. Croatia is eager to formally join the bloc in July of this year, and Serbia is working to remove every possible obstacle before the Council’s decision in the first half of 2013 on setting a date for the start of accession talks. The visit indicates the commitment of the countries to their good-neighborly relations, as befits EU member states.

  • Wm. Dorich

    “Is the Post-2000 Improvement of Relations Between Serbian
    and Croatia Irreversible?”

    Until the Serbs receive an apology and compensation for what they lost during Croatian war crimes in WWII and during the 1990s Civil War there will be no forgiveness. This writer lost 17 relatives burned to death in the Serbian Orthodox church in the Croatian village of Vojnic in 1941, when 97 Serbs were locked inside that church and under the direction of local Roman Catholic priests was burned to the ground. President Franjo Tudjman had the ruins of that church bulldozed in 1995 along with the total destruction of the Jasenovac
    Concentration Camp site where hundred of thousands of Serbs were put to death… Where is my justice?

    When the destruction of the Austrian Empire was an obvious conclusion in WWI, these murderous Croat and Slovene thugs, like rats fleeing a sinking ship ran into the arms of their Serbian enemies to form The Kingdom of Serbs, Croats and
    Slovenes in 1918, a shot-gun marriage made in hell by Churchill and his band of crooked politicians who decided after WWI how the Serbs should live and with whom. Serbia’s enemies, the Croats and Slovenes managed to liquidate 52%
    of Serbia’s adult male population… where is their justice?

    No mention was made in this stupid article that the Serbs were forced to flee their own country in WWI and that the first city lost in that war was Belgrade.
    From the Greek Islands the Serbs were forced to watch their country torn
    apart by Croat fanatics and they had to fight their way back into their own
    country. The first city recaptured by the Serbs was Belgrade. Serbs marched from the beaches of Salonika all the way to the Austrian border to gain the first victory of WWI. However the tombstones at Salonika tell the real story about honor, valor, bravery and the fight for democracy and freedom. There are 40,000 Serbian, 7,000 American and 4,000 Russian tombstones at Salonika.

    No mention is made in this stupid article that Serbia was internationally recognized as a nation at the Congress of Berlin in 1878 or that it was the Serbs who were forced to agree to this shot gun marriage by giving up her nationhood to form The Kingdom of Serbs, Croats and Slovenes. Then as though these
    murderous Croats were not guilty of these hideous war crimes they then gladly
    joined their Nazi comrades in 1941 to tear The Kingdom apart where these Croats and Bosnian Muslims joined the Nazi movement and liquidated over 1.4 million Serbs, 40,000 Jews and 80,000 Roma citizens of Yugoslavia. Not a single one was brought to justice.

    There is not a Serbian family today that did not lose a family member or relative to this Nazi Genocide during the Holocaust in which over 100,000 Serbian children under the age of ten years were liquidated by Roman Catholic nuns at the Jasenovac Concentration Camp…(known by historians as The Auschwitz of the Balkans) this article omits these hideous war crimes and that old, and tire slogan of Tito’s comes back to haunt the Serbs…”Brotherhood” my ass! That was the same wedge used by Tito who forbade the Serbs to even talk about their victimology or the crimes against their families. Croats are quite good at
    making the Serbs the heavy, however history and facts are on the side of the
    Serbs if this stupid media would print the truth.

    More than 4,000 Roman Catholic priests in Croatia participated in the Holocaust in Croatia and personally murdered Serbs with their own hands, then these priests fled through the “Vatican Ratline” for Argentina where not a single one was ever brought to justice. Even Ante Pavelic, the president of the First
    Nazi Independent State of Croatia (1941) fled through the “ratline” and became
    the Security Advisor to Juan Peron who issued 34,000 visas to Croatian war
    criminals so that they, too, could escape justice. Pretending to have amnesia about these war crimes that were followed by the total ethnic cleansing of Croatia of Serbian people from 1991 to 1995 is moronic and only reveals that they are trying to hide the facts that 98 Serbian Orthodox churches were destroyed and entire Serbian villages and more than 100,000 Serbian homes went up in smoke. Today, Croatia is ethnically and religiously pure. Combined with their priesthood skills at molesting children the Catholic Church has become a moral void. Killing Serbian Orthodox Christians has been a goal for the past century and they have proven quite skillful at the task.

    During WWII over 20,000 Nazi Bosnian Muslims had the despicable task of guarding the railway links between the Balkans and Auschwitz. Here we are 70 years later and the offspring of those fanatic Nazi Muslims destroyed 400 Serbian Orthodox Churches in Bosnia and their Albanian Muslim comrades have destroyed 514 Serbian Orthodox churches in Kosovo since the end of the American bombing. The eradication of the Serbs and their religious institutions have been a Muslim goal since the destruction of the Ottoman Empire in 1918. What a disgrace that the American government have aided and abetted their goals as these same American politicians ignore the fact that the Serbs were American allies in two World Wars.

    Today there are 1.2 million Serbian refugees in Serbia, which is twice the number of Croat, Bosnian Muslim and Albanian Muslims combined. So it is
    rather obvious who was the most skilled at this despicable process. Less than
    1.5% of these victims have been allowed to return to their homes and their
    property.

    Again, I don’t give a rat’s ass what some dumb Serbian politician thinks about a relationship with Croats who twice in my lifetime perpetrated Genocide on my family and the Serbian people. Until the Serbian people receive apologies from their former enemies and until the $60 billion in damage to their country has been repaired and until Serbian victims receive restitution, there will be no forgiveness.

    ______________________________________________

    William Dorich, Los Angeles

    The writer is the author of 6 books on Balkan history, including his 1992 book, Kosovo; Jasenovac Then & Now: A Conspiracy of Silence; Serbian Genocide 1941-45 and his current book Serbia: Faces & Places. He is the recipient of The Order of St. Sava, the highest recognition given to a layperson by the Holy Synod of Serbian Orthodox Bishops and An Award of Merit from the Serbian Bar Association of America.

  • Stev-o

    Its a shame they didn’t get you too.

  • Steve-o

    7000 American tombstones in Salonika? I wonder what else you are lying about?

  • http://www.facebook.com/dadodudo Dado Dudo

    Mr Dorich,

    You are a blatant liar. Not only was the stunning Jasenovac monument NOT destroyed by Tudman, but it is a site of the yearly pilgrimage by Croatian governmental officials where they pay tribute to victims. Why such a cheap, easily discredited lie? Kind of discredits your whole post…

Calendar

February 2013
M T W T F S S
« Jan   Mar »
 123
45678910
11121314151617
18192021222324
25262728